Comments on: Social Media Is Dead - So Says Steve Rubel http://experiencecurve.com/archives/social-media-is-dead-so-says-steve-rubel Social Media and New Marketing Strategy Fri, 8 Aug 2008 21:07:32 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.5.1 By: The Complex Brand » Blog Archive » Get a Life http://experiencecurve.com/archives/social-media-is-dead-so-says-steve-rubel#comment-488 The Complex Brand » Blog Archive » Get a Life Tue, 23 Jan 2007 04:23:21 +0000 http://experiencecurve.com/?p=218#comment-488 [...] And the derision doesn’t end at our agency. Social media die-hard and head of the Edelman Me2Revolution Steve Rubel has even recently argued that social media is dead. His theory is that now that big media is beginning to participate, social media is no longer the realm of the masses. Karl Long takes the position that as long as the masses still have some say in user-generated / social media spheres, it will survive. And Dave Armano agrees, citing the distinct lines between mainstream media and social media and predicts that social media will gain more mainstream credibility. [...] [...] And the derision doesn’t end at our agency. Social media die-hard and head of the Edelman Me2Revolution Steve Rubel has even recently argued that social media is dead. His theory is that now that big media is beginning to participate, social media is no longer the realm of the masses. Karl Long takes the position that as long as the masses still have some say in user-generated / social media spheres, it will survive. And Dave Armano agrees, citing the distinct lines between mainstream media and social media and predicts that social media will gain more mainstream credibility. [...]

]]> By: RSS World » Blog Archive » How to Forge a New American Mandate Via Social Media Political Revolution http://experiencecurve.com/archives/social-media-is-dead-so-says-steve-rubel#comment-487 RSS World » Blog Archive » How to Forge a New American Mandate Via Social Media Political Revolution Wed, 17 Jan 2007 11:27:27 +0000 http://experiencecurve.com/?p=218#comment-487 [...] Robert Scoble stated: “As for how bloggers can play in this process? I think we just are going to come up short in coverage of campaigns when compared to the mainstream press.” I agree with almost all of what Robert did on the trip (based on what I’ve seen so far). That said, I think Robert had his PodTech/video blogging hat on a little too tightly here when making this statement that covered his listening ears! Seperately, Karl Long in his debunking of “Social Media is Dead” stated: “To me the difference between social media and “the media” or “big media” is control and influence. Social media is primarily controlled by the participants, by the viewers, readers, listeners etc. where as traditional media is primarily controlled by an organization with a narrower agenda like a corporation, or a political party.” [...] [...] Robert Scoble stated: “As for how bloggers can play in this process? I think we just are going to come up short in coverage of campaigns when compared to the mainstream press.” I agree with almost all of what Robert did on the trip (based on what I’ve seen so far). That said, I think Robert had his PodTech/video blogging hat on a little too tightly here when making this statement that covered his listening ears! Seperately, Karl Long in his debunking of “Social Media is Dead” stated: “To me the difference between social media and “the media” or “big media” is control and influence. Social media is primarily controlled by the participants, by the viewers, readers, listeners etc. where as traditional media is primarily controlled by an organization with a narrower agenda like a corporation, or a political party.” [...]

]]> By: Sunday Social Media News » Online Marketing Blog http://experiencecurve.com/archives/social-media-is-dead-so-says-steve-rubel#comment-486 Sunday Social Media News » Online Marketing Blog Sun, 07 Jan 2007 18:39:18 +0000 http://experiencecurve.com/?p=218#comment-486 [...] There’s been an interesting thread started by Steve Rubel who claims, more or less, that social media is dead. Hmm. Steve’s PR agency royally screws up not once, not twice, but at least three times when trying to use social media (flogs or paying off bloggers) on behalf of their clients. If your firm performed so poorly and was outed in such an embarrassing manner, wouldn’t you want to distance yourself from the channel as well? [...] [...] There’s been an interesting thread started by Steve Rubel who claims, more or less, that social media is dead. Hmm. Steve’s PR agency royally screws up not once, not twice, but at least three times when trying to use social media (flogs or paying off bloggers) on behalf of their clients. If your firm performed so poorly and was outed in such an embarrassing manner, wouldn’t you want to distance yourself from the channel as well? [...]

]]> By: karl long http://experiencecurve.com/archives/social-media-is-dead-so-says-steve-rubel#comment-485 karl long Sun, 07 Jan 2007 18:33:55 +0000 http://experiencecurve.com/?p=218#comment-485 thanks Paul, actually i got the idea from that whole <a href="http://blog.experiencecurve.com/archives/five-things-you-dont-know-about-me-meme" rel="nofollow">5 things you don't know about me"</a> and other similar memes. The 5 things meme relied upon people tagging 5 other people they wanted to answer the question, I just replicated that for the purpose of trying to get some other opinions :-) It actually worked spectacularly well. thanks Paul, actually i got the idea from that whole 5 things you don’t know about me” and other similar memes. The 5 things meme relied upon people tagging 5 other people they wanted to answer the question, I just replicated that for the purpose of trying to get some other opinions :-) It actually worked spectacularly well.

]]> By: Paul Adams http://experiencecurve.com/archives/social-media-is-dead-so-says-steve-rubel#comment-484 Paul Adams Sun, 07 Jan 2007 15:11:33 +0000 http://experiencecurve.com/?p=218#comment-484 Karl, I really like the idea of tagging people to get their opinion. Not sure if you saw this elsewhere or if it's your own idea but it's great! And highly appropriate to the post content. Paul. Karl,

I really like the idea of tagging people to get their opinion. Not sure if you saw this elsewhere or if it’s your own idea but it’s great!

And highly appropriate to the post content.

Paul.

]]> By: David &#8220;Dsquared&#8221; Dalka - Creating Revenue and Retention - Chicago GSB MBA &#187; How to Forge a New American Mandate Via Social Media Political Revolution http://experiencecurve.com/archives/social-media-is-dead-so-says-steve-rubel#comment-483 David &#8220;Dsquared&#8221; Dalka - Creating Revenue and Retention - Chicago GSB MBA &#187; How to Forge a New American Mandate Via Social Media Political Revolution Sat, 06 Jan 2007 14:53:08 +0000 http://experiencecurve.com/?p=218#comment-483 [...] Robert Scoble stated: &#8220;As for how bloggers can play in this process? I think we just are going to come up short in coverage of campaigns when compared to the mainstream press.&#8221; I agree with almost all of what Robert did on the trip (based on what I&#8217;ve seen so far). That said, I think Robert had his PodTech/video blogging hat on a little too tightly here when making this statement that covered his listening ears! Seperately, Karl Long in his debunking of &#8220;Social Media is Dead&#8221; stated: &#8220;To me the difference between social media and “the media” or “big media” is control and influence. Social media is primarily controlled by the participants, by the viewers, readers, listeners etc. where as traditional media is primarily controlled by an organization with a narrower agenda like a corporation, or a political party.&#8221; [...] [...] Robert Scoble stated: &#8220;As for how bloggers can play in this process? I think we just are going to come up short in coverage of campaigns when compared to the mainstream press.&#8221; I agree with almost all of what Robert did on the trip (based on what I&#8217;ve seen so far). That said, I think Robert had his PodTech/video blogging hat on a little too tightly here when making this statement that covered his listening ears! Seperately, Karl Long in his debunking of &#8220;Social Media is Dead&#8221; stated: &#8220;To me the difference between social media and “the media” or “big media” is control and influence. Social media is primarily controlled by the participants, by the viewers, readers, listeners etc. where as traditional media is primarily controlled by an organization with a narrower agenda like a corporation, or a political party.&#8221; [...]

]]> By: Anthony Butler http://experiencecurve.com/archives/social-media-is-dead-so-says-steve-rubel#comment-482 Anthony Butler Wed, 03 Jan 2007 19:29:26 +0000 http://experiencecurve.com/?p=218#comment-482 Karl, You have a link on the Google homepage... NIIIICE! Back to the question at hand (nice image btw of you whizzing in the lake): Content is always "sponsored' to some degree. Even a web forum where the content is produced by the participants has someone looking over that content and tacitly approving it or not. He who admins the site... Steve Rubel is just trying to get ahead of the curve here... everything stops being hot at some stage if not outright dying. When that happens, he can say he was the first. All the same, some of the lame attempts by Ford, Coke etc... to create social media do seem to be speeding Web 2.0 to the gallows. arb: Karl,

You have a link on the Google homepage… NIIIICE!

Back to the question at hand (nice image btw of you whizzing in the lake):
Content is always “sponsored’ to some degree. Even a web forum where the content is produced by the participants has someone looking over that content and tacitly approving it or not. He who admins the site…

Steve Rubel is just trying to get ahead of the curve here… everything stops being hot at some stage if not outright dying. When that happens, he can say he was the first. All the same, some of the lame attempts by Ford, Coke etc… to create social media do seem to be speeding Web 2.0 to the gallows.

arb:

]]> By: David &#8220;Dsquared&#8221; Dalka - Creating Revenue and Retention - Chicago GSB MBA &#187; The Growing Conversation Debunking the &#8220;Social Media Is Dead&#8221; Post by Steve Rubel http://experiencecurve.com/archives/social-media-is-dead-so-says-steve-rubel#comment-481 David &#8220;Dsquared&#8221; Dalka - Creating Revenue and Retention - Chicago GSB MBA &#187; The Growing Conversation Debunking the &#8220;Social Media Is Dead&#8221; Post by Steve Rubel Sat, 30 Dec 2006 21:19:03 +0000 http://experiencecurve.com/?p=218#comment-481 [...] Karl Long has a great post on this where he encourages others to chime in on this issue. Follow his links. [...] [...] Karl Long has a great post on this where he encourages others to chime in on this issue. Follow his links. [...]

]]> By: david weiner http://experiencecurve.com/archives/social-media-is-dead-so-says-steve-rubel#comment-480 david weiner Fri, 29 Dec 2006 16:59:01 +0000 http://experiencecurve.com/?p=218#comment-480 Thanks for calling him out ... it's not that social media isn't fading into media media, it's that the way he chose to write about it was so "Die Social Media Die Die Die." Thanks for calling him out … it’s not that social media isn’t fading into media media, it’s that the way he chose to write about it was so “Die Social Media Die Die Die.”

]]> By: Neville Hobson http://experiencecurve.com/archives/social-media-is-dead-so-says-steve-rubel#comment-479 Neville Hobson Fri, 29 Dec 2006 10:45:13 +0000 http://experiencecurve.com/?p=218#comment-479 Thanks, Karl - you've just suggested a great discussion topic for an upcoming FIR. Stay tuned! FWIW, I agree with Steve that the lines have blurred... Thanks, Karl - you’ve just suggested a great discussion topic for an upcoming FIR. Stay tuned!

FWIW, I agree with Steve that the lines have blurred…

]]>